Vintage Cake Recipes
Vintage Cake Recipes
.
In the United States, National Cake Day is today, November 26th, 2017. Apparently this most cakey of all cake days falls on the 26th of each November. Why? I have no idea. But I do know that National Cake Day is a perfect time to share cake and frosting recipes from vintage cookbooks and newspapers. All recipes are straight from Victorian Americana. Vintage Cake Recipes.
.
As I’m a fan of looking at Victorian influences everywhere, I noticed several vintage cake recipes published in various 19th century newspapers and want to share a smattering of them with you here. You’ll notice a distinct lack of instructions, compared to today’s recipes, as home cooks assumed other home cooks simply understood much about the baking process. Tastes obviously differed from them to now.
.
Vintage Cake Recipes in Order of Publication
.

Election Cake Recipe, published in The Louisville Daily Courier of Louisville, Kentucky, on October 28, 1852.
.

Sponge Cake recipe, Cream Cake recipe, and Soda Cake recipe. Published in The Summit County Beacon of Akron, Ohio, on June 1, 1859.
.

Gipsey [sic] Cake Recipe, published in The Summit County Beacon of Akron, Ohio, on February 9, 1860.
.

Almond Cake Recipe and Sponge Cake Recipe, published in The Emporia Weekly News of Emporia, Kansas, on August 31, 1861.
.

Fried cakes. Like funnel cakes? Published in the Feather River Bulletin of Quincy, California on April 1, 1876.
.
![Kristin Holt | Vintage Cake Recipes. An egg-white, sugar, and cocoanut [sic] cake icing recipe, as shared by Winnie S. in Chicago Tribune, July 15, 1876. Kristin Holt | Vintage Cake Recipes. An egg-white, sugar, and cocoanut [sic] cake icing recipe, as shared by Winnie S. in Chicago Tribune, July 15, 1876.](https://www.kristinholt.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/05/Cake-FROSTING-recipe.-Chicago-Tribune.-July-15-1876.png)
An egg-white, sugar, and cocoanut [sic] cake icing recipe, as shared by a Winnie S. in the Chicago Tribune of Chicago, Illinois on July 15, 1876.
.
BUFFALO CREAM CAKE.
To the Editor of The Tribune.
.
ELGIN, Nov. 5–This recipe is for “Gracie Mayhue.” Buffalo Cream Cake: One egg, one cup sugar, one tablespoonful butter, two-thirds cup milk, one teaspoon baking-powder, one teaspoon vanilla, one and two-thirds cup flour, salt, and bake as for jelly-cake, in three layers.
.
Cream for the above–Heat one pint of milk, and add to it one tablespoonful of corn-starch dissolved in a little milk, two eggs, one cup of sugar, all beaten together: boil it until it thickens. Split the cake when cold and fill with cream. Very nice.
.
J.V.C.
.
~ Chicago Tribune, November 11, 1876
.
I would like to relate a few incidents relating to the girl question, but forbear for want of space. I have a recipe for orange shortcake that can be prepared in a few moments, and is but very little expense: Peel the oranges, and chop very fine; to two oranges take half of a lemon: squeeze the juice and chop the rest: one tea-cup of sugar. Bake a crust as for short-cake: cut open, butter well, and lay the orange between.
.
“DISTRESS.”
.
~ Chicago Tribune of Chicago, Illinois, on December 16, 1876
.

Orange and Luncheon Cake. Published in the Chicago Tribune of Chicago, Illinois, on December 23, 1876.
.

Jumble Recipe, and tips to keep a custard pie from soaking the crust. Published in the Chicago Tribune of Chicago, Illinois, on May 18, 1878.
.

Calico Cake Recipe, from The Home Messenger Book of Tested Recipes, 2nd ed., 1878, by Isabella Stewart.
.

Fruit or Currant Cake, and A Good Custard. Recipes published in The Indiana Progress of Indiana, Pennsylvania, on February 6, 1879.
.

Mock Loaf Cake Recipe. The Inter Ocean of Chicago, Illinois, on February 16, 1883.
.

Blackberry Cake, Prune Cake. Recipes from Our New Cookbook and Household Receipts. Published 1883.
.

Josephine Cake, Jenny Lind Cake, and Jefferson Cake recipes. Recipes from Our New Cookbook and Household Receipts. Published 1883.
.

Icing (white sugar and egg, cooked) published in The Monroeville Breeze of Monroeville, Indiana on July 31, 1884.
.

Melissa’s Shortcake (using self-rising flour), published in The Sunday Leader of Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvania, on May 30, 1886.
.

Boiled Icing, submitted by Susan H. Kerr of Brady Street, Attica, Indiana, and published in The Indianapolis Star on May 9, 1911.
.
Related Articles
.
Updated August 2021
Copyright © 2017 Kristin Holt LC
Vintage Cake Recipes Vintage Cake Recipes